|
CONSISTENT WITH THE
student-based philosophy and practice of
the Oral History Program (OHP) at California State University,
Fullerton (CSUF),
its extensive Japanese American Oral
History Project (JAOHP)
was launched in 1972 at the urging of a
then CSUF
undergraduate history major, Betty E.
Mitson. Mitson was enrolled concurrently in an introductory oral history
class taught by Professor Gary L. Shumway, the founding director of the CSUF
program and a pioneer in the national oral
history movement, and in a historical methodology class under my tutelage.
Coincidentally, she had chosen to sharpen her technical processing skills
in oral history by transcribing, editing, and indexing a series of
tape-recorded interviews in the OHP collection pertinent to the World
War II Japanese American Evacuation, the very topic I had selected for
investigation by the students in my Historical Methods class.
At this point, I knew virtually nothing
about either the method of oral history or the subject of the Evacuation.
My motivation for assigning each student in my class to write a research
paper on some aspect of the wartime removal and incarceration of West
Coast Japanese Americans was that the thirty-year anniversary of this
event afforded a convenient way of imparting historical perspective to the
contemporary concern with civil liberties, human rights, and ethnic
consciousness. Mitson soon convinced me that she could spend her time for
my class more profitably by doubling her processing efforts relative to
the Evacuation tapes and by collecting and collating research materials
for exploitation by her classmates.
One immediate result of this arrangement
was that, in reviewing Mitson’s processing work, I was plunged into every
facet of the oral history process via the topic of the Japanese American
Evacuation. Before long I found myself becoming less Mitson’s teacher than
her student, as she instructed me both in the art of oral history
interviewing and transcript editing. Moreover, the dynamic, dialogical
character of the oral history data that I was working with had the effect
of deepening my understanding of and stimulating my curiosity about the
entire subject of the Evacuation. Mitson then encouraged me to suggest
Professor Shumway that the OHP formally constitute a project pivoting upon
the history and culture of Japanese Americans, with particular attention
being paid to the events surrounding World War II. Upon receiving
Shumway’s enthusiastic endorsement for this idea, the JAOHP, with Mitson
as associate director and myself as director, became a reality.
During its twenty-year history, the project
has evolved through three stages of development. This first stage
extended through 1975, at which time Mitson accepted an appointment as an
oral historian for the Forest History Society, and I succeeded Shumway as
the CSUF—OHP’s second director. The high tide of this stage was reached
in 1974 with the publication of Voices Long Silent: Oral History and
the Japanese American Evacuation (co-edited by Mitson and myself),
an anthology of project interviews, interpretive essays grounded in these
interviews, and taped lectures delivered by selected interviewees in a
University of California, Irvine, Extended Education
series that I coordinated. The annotated bibliography of project holdings
that we prepared for that volume is instructive. It shows that the
project had inherited thirteen interviews conducted for the OHP between
1966 and 1972, all with individuals residing in Orange County, California,
who, for the most part, were of Japanese ancestry and had been interned
during the war in the PostonWar Relocation Center in
southwestern Arizona.
More importantly, it indicates that within the next
two years project members generated seventy-three new interviews, and that
these taped recollections encompassed the Evacuation experiences of
Japanese Americans and non-Japanese Americans from all over California,
though particularly from the Los Angeles area—the prewar residential,
commercial, and cultural center of the mainland Japanese American
community.
In addition to addressing the situations prevalent for
evacuees at the nine other War Relocation Authority (WRA) centers apart
from Poston, especially the Manzanar center in eastern California that
housed primarily evacuees from Los Angeles County, these interviews
embraced the reminiscences of 1) Japanese Americans who had been detained
temporarily in many of the fifteen assembly centers managed by the Wartime
Civil Control Administration (WCCA); ) resident Japanese aliens deemed
“potentially dangerous” who were interned in one or more of the several
centers administered by the United States Department of Justice;
3)children and grandchildren of the evacuees capitalizing upon the
symbolic meaning of the Evacuation as activists in contemporary movements
of ethnic consciousness-cum-cultural politics; 4) Caucasians who had been
employed by the WRA as camp administrators; and 5) non-Japanese residents of the small communities in the regions close to
the sites of the former California camps of Manzanar and Tule Lake. The
latter was located near the Oregon border and was converted during the war
from a regular relocation center to a segregation center for Japanese
Americans deemed “disloyal.”
What is less clear from perusing the
annotated bibliography in Voices Long Silent is how this profusion
of interviews came into existence. Although Mitson and I were directly
responsible for the production of a substantial number of them, the bulk
of the interviews derived from students enrolled in successive seminars on
the Evacuation taught by the two of us. During this interval, individual
and group forays into the field by project members netted an array of oral
memoirs falling into categories noted above. The two most prominent
student interviewers during this phase of the project, David Bertagnoli
and Sherry Turner, undertook prolonged fieldwork with the aforementioned
townspeople living adjacent, respectively, to the Manzanar and Tule Lake
campsites. Then, too, other undergraduate student interviewers, notably
David Hacker and Ronald Larson, substantially enlarged and enhanced the
project’s holdings by conducting key interviews with controversial
personalities involved in intracamp policies at the Manzanar center.
Finally, two other undergraduate interviewers, Janis Gennawey and Pat
Tashima, played important roles during this period through the multiple
interviews each added to the project’s mushrooming archival collection.
The next stage of the project’s development
extended through 1980. This stage saw the addition of some thirty-five
interviews, falling largely within four topical foci: 1) internees and
administrators of alien internment centers; 2) celebrated dissidents at WRA centers; 3)
Japanese American community leaders in Orange County, California; and 4)
residents of the southwestern Arizona communities
proximate to the former Poston War Relocation Center. The interviews comprising the last two categories were collected,
respectively, under the aegis of seminars that I taught in conjunction
with Ronald Larson and Jesse Suzuki Garrett in 1976, and with David Hacker
in 1978. Each of these individuals, along with Susan McNamara, Eleanor
Amigo, Paul Clark, and Betty Mitson, at one or another time during this
phase of the project saw service as the project’s
director.
More central and, perhaps, more
consequential than interviewing in this period, however~ was the technical
processing and interpretation of the amassed oral data. Owing to a
contractual arrangement between the
OHP and Microfilming Corporation of
America (MCA), a New York Times subsidiary, project
personnel were obliged to transcribe, edit, and index our holdings so
that they could be disseminated internationally by MCA in a microform edition. In addition to the project directors named above,
three other project members—Paula Hacker, Elizabeth Stein, and Mary Reando—were
instrumental in converting raw tapings into polished archival documents.
With respect to the interpretive work
accomplished in this stage, project members produced not only two
more published anthologies of its interviews, but also two
unpublished CSUF Department of History master’s theses
and one lengthy scholarly monograph based upon project material.The
first of the anthologies, Japanese Americans in Orange County:
Oral Perspectives, was edited with an introduction by Eleanor
Amigo in 1976. More ambitious in scope, as well as more
controversial in nature, was the 1977 anthology, co-edited and
introduced by Jesse Garrett and Ronald Larson and showcasing the
interviews transacted by David Bertagnoli and myself entitled
Camp and Community: The two
theses, authored by Paul Clark and David Hacker, were completed in
1980 under my supervision. Clark’s study, “Those Other Camps: An
Oral History Analysis of Japanese Alien Enemy Internment during
World War II,” revolved around interviews he recorded (some with the translation
assistance of Mariko Yamashita, a Japanese exchange student at CSUF affiliated with the project) with
former internees and administrators of Department of Justice camps for
enemy aliens. The thesis by Hacker, “A Culture Revived: The Loyalty Crisis
of 1943 at the Manzanar War
Relocation Center,” was informed by the many interviews in the
project impinging upon developments at Manzanar, particularly an intensive
three-day interview conducted jointly by Hacker and myself in the spring
of 1978 in Norman, Oklahoma, with Dr. Morris Opler. A professor emeritus
of anthropology at both Cornell University and the University of Oklahoma, Opler, during World War II, had headed Manzanar’s Community Analysis
Section. As for the unpublished monograph, “Doho: The Japanese American
‘Communist’ Press, 1937—1942,” it was authored by Ronald Larson and
anchored by interviews done by himself and others.
The project’s third stage, persisting into
[1992] and encompassing some thirty-five new interviews, has been
characterized by cooperative ventures undertaken with outside agencies
and individuals. The first of these had its origins in a 1976 project
interview with the central figure in the so-called Manzanar Riot of
December 1942, Harry Y. Ueno. This endeavor was capped by a widely
circulated and critically acclaimed 1986 project publication, Manzanar
Martyr: An Interview with Harry Y. Ueno, co-edited and introduced by
Sue Kunitomi Embrey, the wartime editor of the camp newspaper at Manzanar
and the founding chair of the Manzanar Committee (a Los Angeles—based
activist group known principally for leading an annual pilgrimage to the
Manzanar campsite in the Owens Valley), Betty Mitson, and myself.
Go to
page 2 |